Home » LAW »» BUSINESS & FINANCIAL & Corporate LAW

Lost contract - but plenty of email correspondence (CA) (BUSINESS & FINANCIAL & Corporate LAW)

Comments (4) | Promote | Bookmark |

• Leave a Comment Now.
• Comments
• Tue, 29 Sep 2009 21:37:00 GMT(1)
• E-mails are always admissible evidence in court. However, you do not have any e-mails stating the terms, that the contract was signed? This would make it a slam-dunk.
  If the other party erases e-mails, you might bluff your way through just stating that you have e-mails to support your position. But so far, no court action? Don't look for trouble, it has a way of finding you soon enough without looking for it.
• Tue, 29 Sep 2009 23:42:00 GMT(2)
• Well he acknowledges even now that he did - saying "I see in the contract that package #1 is $xxxx, so I owe you $xxxx minus the deposit of $xxxx" (as he has paid a deposit - just saying now that it is a deposit toward a lesser package). Unless that isn't an acknowledgment? He is just trying to say that he didn't choose that package - which again I have an email clearly saying "I want package #2". That plus we did things that weren't included in package #1 (i.e. an engagement session) that were included in package #2. Then I have several emails from before and after the wedding stating the balance owed that he responded to - and never contested.
  He was honest in telling me that the money he owed me went to the hotel (who charged him $6000 more for the extra alcohol) - and I've (every month since) patiently dealt with "I promise it'll be taken care of by the end of the month". Four months later he just now contests the final payment amount and that he still can't pay me for another month. Would this have any impact in court? Plus he thought he paid me a few hundred dollars less in the deposit - and I corrected him and told him he paid me more than that. So I could have at least gotten a few extra hundred dollars back there - but chose to be honest. All of that is through email, so I wonder if this would help with the judge?
  Either way, since he now says that he currently has the contract and refers to it in our discussions (referring to it in talks with me implies it is the binding agreement at hand, I'm assuming?) he would be acknowledging that he had signed the same contract that had the late payment of $100 per week included in it (regardless of the package chosen), would he not? This is assuming that the attachment I have is in fact proof that he received the same contract that I would bring to court.
  I have proof that he has received PART of the photos (he doesn't contest this). I've done the work for the last part, which he is saying he never wanted (when I have emails saying otherwise). It's about a $2000 difference. So if I couldn't get him to pay me for package #2, I'm wondering would I be able to get the $2000 back in the late fees? What do you think my likelihood would be there? I don't care about OVER suing - just getting the same amount I was contracted to expect. If that's by him being forced to pay the package price we agreed to OR by him being forced to pay package #1 (which he now says he wanted in contradiction to our emails) plus the $2000 in late fees - I don't mind.
  Again, you have no idea how much I appreciate your input. Seriously.
• Tue, 29 Sep 2009 22:33:00 GMT(3)
• He never actually acknowledged that he did agree to this contract.
  Do you have proof that he received and accepted the pictures that were part of the package he chose?
  If he did and did not e-mail that he received something that was part of this package, it should strengthen your claim.
  Small claims court is not a huge financial investment for you to file with no lawyer fees, etc. If you think he should pay, he should be taken to small claims.
  You stated that he is five months late paying. Has he made any payments? If he has made even one payment on this package, he is admitting his debt and it should be held up in court easily.
• Tue, 29 Sep 2009 22:25:00 GMT(4)
• Thanks so much for your reply! Really, I appreciate it so much Nothing but emails have happened at this point (no legal actions taken).
  To give a better idea, I'm a photographer. This person booked X package. He's five months late on payment. He now says he wants to pay for the less expensive package even though he's received part of what the more expensive package entailed. There is also a late payment fee of $100 per week in the contract (20 weeks = $2000 - but I'd be fine with not getting that if I simply got paid what I'm owed). Maybe that gives more context
  I do have pricing packages spelled out in an email, a response from him saying "I'll take THAT package, an email of me emailing him the contract (with the contract attached - this would be proof of WHICH contract he in fact received as I wouldn't be able to change the attachment on an email already sent), an email of him saying he received it and is bringing it by "tomorrow", another email later (after the wedding - just recently) acknowledging that he has the contract and is looking at it (again - it could only be the one attached as I can't reattach anything to an email already sent - so it should be solid that he is acknowledging that he has the contract that I would be saying was our contract.).
  So do you think this would be something I could win in a small claims court? It's a difference of owing me $1900 and $4000 ($6000 with the late payment that I don't intend on pursuing unless a) it's something I could win and b) he does things that asks for it. At this point, full payment is fine even though I've been waiting ages for payment). If I have to, I'll go see a lawyer, but I'm currently trying to retire my parents and that's where my financial priorities are at the moment. And if he fights me on it, is the $100 late payment clause something I could go after if he really makes me fight for it? Again, I wouldn't want to pursue that unless he just asks for it - just curious if you think it's something I could purse.
  Seriously, thanks so much again.
• Leave a Comment Now.

BUSINESS & FINANCIAL & Corporate LAW Open Questions

What is the name of your state? AZ I lost a check that was sent to me in payment for the sale of land in Montana. I have tried to contact the person that issued the check, but he will not return any of my calls. I have contacted his attorney, dad, and grandpa and they all say they will pass the......

State (would rather not say at this time - for obvious reasons) I am not sure if this is the correct place to ask this question, so forgive me if I've goofed. I have a relative that has found a very-very large sum of money in their bank account. The family is wondering what are the legal......

We have either lost or misplaced our common stock certificate representing a significant number of shares in a large American corporation. In the worst case our certificate may have been stolen. Because of this situation, we have the following legal concerns and questions: 1) Is the certificate......

What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Florida can we sue or not? situation: applied for loan and $500 was requested as insurance against the $5000 loan...Sterling Financial Services...did not receive refund of $500 nor $5000 for loan....

undefinedWhat is the name of your state? New Jersey I work for a small business which had a $2m/yr. contract with a Fortune 100 business for the 5 years. We lost the contact and it was awarded to another company. In general, this loss will cause our company to loose a lot of revenue, and......

Hi, I am a ticket broker in CA and I am being threatened a lawsuit by a ticket broker in NY. I sold tickets to this business for a concert in NY. I sold 8 tickets to him at 450 each. He then resold them at a higher amount (assuming). I purchased the tickets I sold him from another party who is......

What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state? Texas I own a small business in Texas. A client owes me quite a lot of money from the year 2003. All previous negotiation attempts and commitments have failed. Because I have not been able to collect this money, I have used all of my......

We were involved in a Multi-Level-Marketing scheme that we paid into to receive a commission on sales. We invested a few thousand dollars to belong to the Group that also paid the advertising. We were buying small "business centers" and were paid commission on centers that started under......

What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state?NV My business was an S Corp in NV. There were three partners/stockholders of equal share. Myself and two gentleman from AZ. We had been discussing for a couple of weeks the two of them buying my intrest due to an inability yo see......

I have developed a software application that I'm looking to sell to the company that I am employed by. And though this application was developed prior to being hired by the company (and I have not used any company time to develop or promote my product), I'm leery of the legal ramifications that......

Some questions maybe you're interest in...

[Real Estate & Property Law] I live in a subdivision in southern indiana. I have lived here since July 1994 and just this year I was told I could not have my boat in my driveway any longer and "according to the covenants" had to move it. I received a phone call stating that I had 30 days to remove it or the leader.........

[Insurance Law] My question involves insurance law for the state of: New York I was recently involved in a hit and run on a parked car. But told the insurance company that I was hit by somone who ran a red light. The owner of the parked car has filed an insurance claim aginst me. I have full coverage and my.........

[Consumer Law & Fraud] I traded in a very nice vehicle for a beat up pick -up truck in an attempt to get out of debt. As part of the deal, the dealer was to pay off my lien. Right before the trade, I had sent $4,000 toward the principle. He never paid off the truck. I didn't find out until months later, due to my large.........

[COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION] I want to file a small claims action in Utah with an LLC that has failed to refund money for services not rendered due to the death of my father. Do I list myself as Defendant, or my father, or the name of the family trust in which all his assets were held. Thanks, Kristen......

[Traffic Law] What is the name of your state? Georgia I pulled out of a service station onto a four lane city street -- three lanes for through traffic and the leftmost lane for left turns. There was no traffic at all on the through lanes (the light to my left was red, keeping back the traffic) but there was a.........

[CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE] I live in California. I was born in December of 1990. My girlfriend was born in June of 1991. My parents claim that I shouldn't go on a trip I've been planning overnight with her because of the risk of "violating statutory rape laws." In otherwords if we broke up and she was bitter, my.........

[Government & Administrative Law] What is the name of your state? Ohio If the juvenile court violated my due process rights by omitting the necessary adjudicatory phase in neglect proceedings but adjudicated my son neglected and dependent anyways and granted custody of my son to grandparents even though I was fit and the.........

[Wills & Trusts] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? MS I inherited a home from my great-grandmother, the will reads fee simple absolute the house belongs to me. The will also gives life-interest in the property to my grandfather(her son). He is also the executor. For the last few years we have lived.........

[Wills & Trusts] I live in Sacramento, California. Is there somewhere on the web I can find an example of a condicil? I need to add instructions.......

[Consumer Law & Fraud] I sold a miniature horse to a young lady. She signed the contract and paid the down payment. Now she has defaulted on the contract by not making her payments on this animal. I want to pick my mare up and return her to my home, now I find out she was 17 when she signed this contract. Her parent's.........