Home » LAW »» COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION
Liability/Due Process: 3rd Party (non-owner) Vehicle Impound (COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION)
Sat, 07 Feb 2009 04:04:00 GMTState of California (Los Angeles County)
First off, many thanks for all the great advice people have given on this site! My question is both complicated and somewhat confusing, so I will try to be clear. This is a good challenge for the experts.
About four months ago, I helped my sister ("Steff") sell her car, a 1996 Honda Civic. She sold the car to a family friend ("Kevin"). Kevin at the time was down on his luck due to very bad health. We were trying to help him out, so we gave the car to him on good faith, i.e. no actual upfront payment. Kevin was to pay us within a couple of weeks. He was given the signed title to transfer the car into his name. I had Steff fill out DMV forms for bill of sale (yes, without the actual payment) and waiver of liability. Steff failed to turn in DMV paperwork, she forgot.
A week after the vehicle transfer, the car was impounded in L.A. county because Kevin had a seizure on the freeway. A police report was written, I have not seen it. Anyways, the tow company notified Steff of the impound TWO WEEKS after the fact. The company got the address from the DMV (Dept. of Motor Vehicle's). When Steff received the notice, she called the tow company and said she was no longer the owner. However, the tow company claimed she was responsible because the DMV still had her as the registered owner. Steff called the DMV and got the same information.
Two weeks into the impound, the tow company wanted over a thousand dollars to release the vehicle. My sister and I were surprised by how long the tow company took to send us notice. Due to lack of proof of ownership and a medical hold on his driver's license, Kevin could not get the car out of impound.
We ourselves did not have the money to get the car out; a few weeks later (about a month after initial impound) the car was sold at auction and we were sent a bill from the tow company in the amount of 1300.00, the remaining balance of the total impound fees. We did not pay, and about two weeks later (about 6 weeks after initial impound) we received a bill for 1300.00 from a collection agency. I am guessing that ethier the debt was sold by the tow company or the collection agency is on commission. On the hook for 1300.00 and out of a car, I started searching California law for help. In my research, I discovered section 14602.6.
(2) The impounding agency, within two working days of impoundment, shall send a notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the legal owner of the vehicle, at the address obtained from the department, informing the owner that the vehicle as been impounded. Failure to notify the legal owner within two working days shall prohibit the impounding agency from charging for more than 15 days impoundment when the legal owner redeems the impounded vehicle. The impounding agency shall maintain a published telephone number that provides information 24 hours a day regarding the impoundment of vehicles and the rights of a registered owner to request a hearing.
The tow company claims to have sent us notice by mail within the time allowed by law, we never received anything. Obviously, if notice was sent by certified mail, then there would not be any issues regarding that. Had we knew of the impound within the four days (2 weekend, 2 working), we would have been able to get the car out of impound.
My idea is to take the tow company to small claims on the basis that we lost the car due to their mistake in not following impound procedure. I will ask for 2500.00, the value of the car (Kelly Blue Book) and the 1300.00 that is in collections, since it appears we will still have to pay the collection agency for the tow company's error. There seems to be only two possible outcomes: 1. the court acknowledges our ownership of the car (giving us a legal basis for our claim) or 2. the court rejects our ownership of the car, which would mean Steff can't be held reponsible for the outstanding impound fees.
Wow, that was long.....what do you think?
And by the way, Kevin has since decided not to pay Steff for the car or take reponsiblity for the impound; needless to say, he is no longer a family friend.
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? California
(8) | Promote | Bookmark |
- Leave a Comment Now.
- Comments
- Sat, 07 Feb 2009 16:29:00 GMT(1)
- hum, thanks. When I say we, i mean my sister and I. Obviously, I have no claim to the car, I am just helping my sister out**.
Does it not seem there is a double standard? How can my sister still be legally responsible for the car (according to DMV) but not have a right to be properly notified by the tow company, thus giving her a chance to get the car out in a timely manner? Would not the court also recognize Steff as the legal owner? Before the impound, the ownership paperwork for the car was not done properly and Steff never received payment from Kevin, In fact, the tow company assumes that Steff has always been the owner, they have no knowledge of the situiation between Kevin and Steff.
Perhaps the section code I quoted was in error? - Sat, 07 Feb 2009 20:17:00 GMT(2)
- thanks for the insight, I appreciate all your advice, sounds like your real knowledgeable in this area....
In my original post, I stated that there was a police report, which neither I nor Steff has had a chance to review. When Steff finally found out from the tow company that the car was impounded, she called Kevin. Kevin stated the car was impounded for "medical reasons." Steff does not actually know for a fact that the car was NOT impounded for a criminal offense (i.e. driving under the influence of prescription drugs), this is because she knew Kevin took heavy medication for his health. If there is a police report in existence for this matter, would that indicate that a criminal offense might have been committed? Are police reports a matter of public record? If the car was actually impounded for a criminal offense, does Steff have a valid case against the tow company? - Sat, 07 Feb 2009 16:31:00 GMT(3)
- Is there not a due process law in California for when a car is impounded without the owner's (in this case, Steff) knowledge?
Does this section of California Law apply:
Notice to Owner: Poststorage Hearing
22852. (a) Whenever an authorized member of a public agency directs the storage of a vehicle as permitted under this section, or upon the storage of any vehicle as permitted herein (except as provided in subdivision (f) or (g)), the agency or person directing the storage shall provide the vehicle's registered and legal owners of record, or their agents, with the opportunity for a poststorage hearing to determine the validity of the storage. - Fri, 23 Oct 2009 01:01:00 GMT(4)
- What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? California.
I sold a car back in March of 2008 however I failed to file a release of liability. When I sold the car I was paid with a credit union check so me assuming that since there was now a lien holder(the Bank) on the car the proper registration process would have occurred but it didnt. So now in Oct of 2009 I recieve a letter from a collection agency stating I owe them $2200 because all fees werent recovered at the auction and I was the last registered owner. I dont understand if the bank issued a check they would have became the legal owner of the car, right? I also have a handwritten Bill of sale signed and dated by both myself and the buyer.. Please tell me what to do as the agency said I was liable? Thanks...... - Sat, 07 Feb 2009 18:31:00 GMT(5)
Quote:
|
Does it not seem there is a double standard? How can my sister still be legally responsible for the car (according to DMV) but not have a right to be properly notified by the tow company, thus giving her a chance to get the car out in a timely manner?
|
Nope. The initial responsibility for notification of the tow was the person driving the car at the time it was towed. In this type of situtation, the tow was not considered an impoundment due to a violation of the law, it was a private tow requested by the police. She was given a chance to get the vehicle back in a timely manner. Remember from your first post?
Quote:
|
Anyways, the tow company notified Steff of the impound TWO WEEKS after the fact.
|
It is not the towing company's fault your sister could not afford the impound. It also appears she could not afford the responsibility selling a vehicle in a manner that could have protected her. Also, if she had been notified of the tow by the responsible party, she could have migated her damages.
Quote:
|
Would not the court also recognize Steff as the legal owner?
|
Yes and it appears there were 2 failures in the process, this means your sister is legally liable for the vehicle and the monies owed. There was no transfer of title and no report of sale made to the state.
Quote:
|
Before the impound, the ownership paperwork for the car was not done properly and Steff never received payment from Kevin, In fact, the tow company assumes that Steff has always been the owner, they have no knowledge of the situiation between Kevin and Steff.
|
Now you get the idea.
Quote:
|
Perhaps the section code I quoted was in error?
|
As stated, it does not apply.
Quote:
|
Is there not a due process law in California for when a car is impounded without the owner's (in this case, Steff) knowledge?
|
In most cases, due process applies to criminal acts and one's rights when facing charges. Everything with this tow was a civil action, there is no cause for due process.
Quote:
Does this section of California Law apply:
Notice to Owner: Poststorage Hearing
22852. (a) Whenever an authorized member of a public agency directs the storage of a vehicle as permitted under this section, or upon the storage of any vehicle as permitted herein (except as provided in subdivision (f) or (g)), the agency or person directing the storage shall provide the vehicle's registered and legal owners of record, or their agents, with the opportunity for a poststorage hearing to determine the validity of the storage.
|
Probably not. The tow, even if requested by an authorized member of a public agency, was not caused due to a violation of the law. As stated above, the towing company considered the tow a private tow. Much like when a vehicle is towed from an auto accident. The owner of the vehicle is liable the moment the tow truck picks up the vehicle.
As I stated in my previous post, there is only there are 2 negligent parties and they must be held accountable for the costs associated with the tow and storage fees. One is your sister for not filing a report of sale within the 7 days as prescribed by law. The other is Kevin for not transferring ownership of the vehicle then not notifying your sister of the tow in a timely manner.- Tue, 10 Feb 2009 09:13:00 GMT(6)
- As stated above, unforunately theres not a whole lot you can do about your situation based on the way you handled it. Your best bet would be to sue Kevin. However, you dont have any paperwork signed from Kevin promising to pay you for the car. Without at least a promissory note stating basis of the transaction, you dont have any defense. The certified notification doesn't apply to you because the vehicle was taken directly from the driver, which in that case you're given a actual impound notification at the time of impound. Usually a few weeks later, you'll receive another(actual registered owner) to make certain you are aware in the event someone else was driving the vehicle at the time of impoundment, as you did. Kevin could have never retrieved the vehicle because legally he was never the owner. the medical hold and all that sounds legit because that is how its handled in the event of a seizure. He has to be medically cleared by a physician and Drivers Safety dept to ever get on the road again legally. It was Kevin's responsibility to tell you when the vehicle was impounded so that you can retrieve the vehicle incurring the least amount of fees possible. You cant fight the tow company for negligence, you cant fight the DMV without submitted paperwork, and dear god, you cant fight Kevin because unfortunately you dont have the proof to do it. We live and learn lessons everyday! I'm DMV knowledgable heres some cheap advice that will go a long way in the future for covering yourself in these type of instances. If you decide to be nice, still get the basis of the contract in writing. Most important when selling a car, complete a release of liability. DO NOT DROP IN IN THE EXPRESS BOX! YOU STILL HAVE NO PROOF DMV GOT IT. You must stand in the start here line, have your form dateline stamped, leave and make a copy for yourself, then return and drop it in the box. has to be done that way for proof to be considered when something like this happens. Also 2 more piece of info that might help you the next time. You can pay a transfer fee to start the process and establish new ownership which is about $15-20 and a bill of sale. although the transfer process is not complete because of other fees and requirements, the new owner is established on record which in turn releases your liability or she could have paid that same $15-20 and established herself as the legal owner(meaning he still hasn't paid off the car, like a leinholder) and Kevin as the registered owner. As legal owner you're still notified of any info pertaining to the vehicle but your not the responsible party for anything that occurs. Sorry to hear no good deed goes unpunished. Hope this info will be helpful for you in the future.
- Sat, 07 Feb 2009 08:01:00 GMT(7)
- You can do nothing, the car was not yours. Your sister at this time has no claim for a lawsuit against the towing company, she has suffered no monetary losses due to them at this time. Owing money in not considered a monetary loss. But your sister did suffer a monetary loss and it was caused by the buyer of the vehicle. At this time it would be for the value of the vehicle itself. She might, but it would be a stretch at this point, to sue the buyer for the cost of the impound. If she pays the $13 , then she definitely could. The statute you quoted does not apply, it addresses vehicles towed when the operator is driving without a valid driver's license. The tow would be of a civil nature. Kevin should have notified your sister of the tow and and the likelyhood she could be held liable due to his failure to transfer ownership into his name. Please stop with the we stuff, you have no dog in this fight.
- Tue, 10 Feb 2009 18:13:00 GMT(8)
- thanks, I appreciate the advice, an excellent response....seems like u understand the situiation, and unfortunately, I was punished for not protecting myself.
COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION Open Questions
Liability Waiverwe live in southern oregon, and have a large piece of property in the country. we'd like some information about allowing people on the property with the use of a liability waiver.. against accident, injury, etc. something like a paper that says 'enter at your own risk'....
liability of spouse in civil suitWhat is the name of your state? CA
is a spousal bank account subject to liability and collection or garnishment in a civil suit against the other spouse?...
liability of parents for minors action?What is the name of your state? Ohio
My son pleaded gulity to GSI only because we were told to do so by counsel. We were not even through the sentencing part of the criminal hearings then we were contacted by attornies asking us to turn our letter over to our homeowners policy for fair......
Liability of a shoe cobblerWhat is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? California
Hi All,
Just got back from a heated discussion with a shoe cobbler... have always wondered if there existed a less antiquated way to speak of someone in this profession but I digress ... and was hoping you all could lend me some insight......
Liability In MinnesotaNot sure if this is the right forum for this or not but I'll give it a shot anyway. I have worked at a small lumber yard, privately owned, for about 2 years now in Minnesota. My daily duties include loading job materials, usually with a forklift. About a week ago, I was loading a steel package......
Liability from wedding receptionMy daughter is getting married in Virginia. My wife and I am concerned about our liability due to liquor being served. We are from Connecticut and unfamiliar with Virginia. Virginia does not appear to have a dram shop law or social host law. The bride and groom are making the wedding; we are......
Liability & verdict...What is the name of your state? WI
I'm just curious about this - it's not a personal situation, purely hypothetical.
Let's say I am mugged and stabbed by some crook and have to go to the hospital for treatment (and have no insurance). In court, the judge rules the attacker is liable for all my......
liabilityi have a business in nc, i was asked to bake a cake, i was told my payment would left at the place of delivery . i delivered the cake and picked up the payment right on schedule. i was called by the buyer a short time later and was told the cake had fallen and was destroyed, could i possibly go......
Liabilities of "Next Friend"In Oklahoma my Husband,myself and our minor daughter (who turned 18 before the court date) were defendants in a small claims case where we were being sued for damages caused by a party my daughter had while dog sitting for a friend. The judgement against my husband and i was $2,500 and then the......
liabel/witness harassmentWhat is the name of your state? co
i was a witness against a dr in a felony sexual assualt case. i have since been harassed by one of his friends who is also a dr. recently they posted a web site saying i was having an affair with him and lied about the whole case(all false), i should be......
Some questions maybe you're interest in...
Trademark Status[Intellectual Property] My question involves business law in the state of: Florida The name I wanted to use for my new business came up in a search as a registered trademark in the US. I checked the status at the US Patent Office, etc. & the trademark status is "Dead" as of a couple of months ago. Can I.........
Felony on private property update from previous thread[Traffic Law] Just wanted to let you know 'the rest of the story'. I was referred to an attorney thru a 'friend of friend'. The attorney has dealt with the 'towing' company operators before. According to TN law regarding towing procedure, he says that we will be able to charge the towing company with Grand.........
COBRA questions about self-insured plan[Insurance Law] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? CA
Just received COBRA letter with premium costs after a layoff. The employer has three plans - High Deductible PPO, self-funded plan that filled in the High Deductible, and dental.
1) If I choose all three plans for COBRA continuation, can I.........
Judgements?[BANKRUPTCY & CONSUMER CREDIT] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Nevada
I had a credit card with a $300.00 limit over 5 years ago and when my new baby cost $80,000.00 to be born some things just had to be let go! The other day I received a call that said they were turning everything over to the county sherriffs.........
Worried In San Antonio,tx.[BANKRUPTCY & CONSUMER CREDIT] What is the name of your state?TEXAS
IS ANYONE FAMILIAR WITH TITAN RECOVERY GROUP,LLC. I RECENTLY RECIEVED A LETTER FROM THE LAW OFFICE OF LAWRENCE R. BOIVIN OF LAGUNA HILLS, CA. WHO IS REPRESENTING TITAN RECOVERY GROUP. THE ORIGINAL CREDITOR WAS CHASE BANK.
THANKS......
changing a beneficiary[Insurance Law] need to know legal way to sign insurance form.
i am unable to write due to disability.
i am able to make my mark using my mouth.
please tell me how to properly use witnesses etc.
i reside in Kentucky......
The insolence of Office; Hoisting them on their own Petards[Additional Legal Subjects] Thanks to Dan Evans for his insightful and helpful information and to Merlin for pointing out the 11th Amendment. This gives me a good starting place. Now if I just can summon the stamina and resources to take on the state, that would be a major victory. If someone would entertain a followup? Are.........
401k fraud[Accidents & Personal Injury Law] What is the name of your state? NY
I work for a small private company and found out that the company has not been depositing 401k withdrawals from employees check for almost a year but keep the funds and using them for business activities. The funds are managed by a 3rd party financial.........
Criminal versus security checks[Immigration Law] The caips file has two parameters in it: CRIM STATUS SEC STATUS Anybody know the difference between criminal checks and security checks? Also why do criminal checks take longer than security checks?-- Posted via http://britishexpats.com......
Fake Social Security Number[CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE] I am not necessarily asking for advice. I am seeking information about what penalty my daughter's ex-boyfriend may receive. He was ordered to pay child support five years ago and has not paid a cent. The Child Support Enforcement Agency finally caught up with him and discovered that he has been.........