Home » LAW »» CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE

Retail Fraud Civil Demand - When is It Harrassment (CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE)

Sat, 10 Jan 2009 12:13:00 GMT

My question involves criminal law for the state of: Michigan

Ok, it's kinda a long story, but to make it short I was recently fired from my job at a large retailer for "Misappropriation and/or damageof company assets". What happened was my boyfriend gave me a gift card that was for the retailer, I used the gift card, I was then fired for useing the gift card and arrested for thief. The person who fired me told me that they had me on tape stealing the gift card from a customer. While being interrogated by the police it was discovered that she didn't actually see me do anything on the video tape. They asked my boyfriend what happened and he told them he had found the gift card on he ground in the parking lot. Because I had told him at some point in time in the past that a gift card is "just like cash" He didn't think anything of it. I hadn't asked him where he had gotten the gift card and didn't find out until after I'd already used it.

Now I am being harrassed by a Law office for damages. The cardwas worth 40 dollars and I know there is a MI law that says they can charge you up to 200 dollars extra for these sorts of thing. I was never charged with any crime. Nor have they taken me to court, they just keep sending me letters and calling me saying that I owe them money, the last letter they sent says I owe them 665 dollars now, even though I've never been to court. Every time they call I tell them to take me to court because I have no intention of paying anything. It's gotten to the point where I don't think they actually take people to court, they just harrass people until they cave because they just want to move on with there lives. What should I do?

Comments (9) | Promote | Bookmark |

  • Leave a Comment Now.
  • Comments
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 14:42:00 GMT(1)
  • Honestly, all I wanted to get from this thread was when, if ever, I could file harrassment charges against them for not taking me to court. I know that sounds odd, most of the people in this forum are like "yeah I did it, how do I stay away from court?". But I didn't do anything wrong. And I'm being treated like someone who bought something online and is refusing to pay for it. An almost constant stream of threatening letters and calls.

    If they take me to court and I loose, fine. (I honestly don't think I will), but how long can they harrass me and tact on charges before I can say, ENOUGH.

    In my first post I said that this was a fairly recent occurance, in legal terms it probably is, but this actually happened back in September and I've been getting calls and letters sence. And every time my answer is "take me to court". So over 4 months of harrassment. How long before I can say, enough?
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 13:46:00 GMT(2)
  • Quoting panther10758


    If you can prove she lied to police then Police can file charges against her.

    The OP signed a confession.

    The "lie" has documentation provided by the OP that it is the truth.
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 14:08:00 GMT(3)
  • Wow, I thank you all for your imput, but tbh I have no intention of paying anything. I never "confessed" I wrote exactly what happened and was then told to write that I would pay it back by my superior at work. Again, pretty sure thats illigal.

    At far as not having any evidence that my boy friend found it, well, they don't have any evidence that he didn't either. Innocent until proven? Plus no where on a gift card does it say "if found must be returned to <suchandsuch>" In fact, it says "the holder of this card is assumed to be the owner" Otherwise, I could buy anyone a gift card, have them use it, say they stole it from me and then I would get to sue them.

    Plus, I was granted my unemployment after it was denied because I was fired for theft. I had to write a letter detailing everything that had happened, and they found that I had in "no way acted against the best interests" of the company.

    Lastly, I haven't been "ignoreing" these letters, every time one is written or I am called I reply and tell them to take me to court.

    Again thanks for the imput, but sence I didn't do anything wrong, except what I was told to do by my boss, I don't see why I should have to pay these people anything. If a loose, well, at least I fought for what I knew was right.
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 12:33:00 GMT(4)
  • Just because they didn't charge you criminally doesn't mean that they can't sue you in a civil court. Did you ever sign anything agreeing to pay the store back?

    If you ignore the letters, they can take you to court. You should consult with a local attorney.
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 13:07:00 GMT(5)
  • Oh! And I forgot to mention I really don't mind going to court. It'll give me the chance to counter sue, plus there attourny fees have to be mimimal because they have to go through small claims court, where a lawyer cannot even be present.
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 12:44:00 GMT(6)
  • Civil Demand is state law. Unless you want to see this cost rise or possibly go to court (thus costing thousands maybe) you will sadly pay it
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 13:40:00 GMT(7)
  • Well, the state of MI unemployment agency agrees with me that I did nothing wrong, and granted me my unemployment.

    So it was legal for her to lie to the police to get me arrested? Just looking for clarification. The fireing, is well, kinda whatever at this point. Back to my original post they have sent me 4 letters in the mail and called me many times, every time, I reply "take me to court" so far, no court, so when is it harrassment?
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 13:22:00 GMT(8)
  • You will never win that counter suit and your firing was legal
  • Sat, 10 Jan 2009 13:04:00 GMT(9)
  • I did sign something saying I would pay back the cost of the gift card, but that was under distress, My Manager handed me a piece of paper, Told me to write down that I would pay it back and told me to sign it, and That it would all be ok after I did that. I was then fired. I'm pretty sure thats illigal.

    I was also curious if I maybe have a civil case against them for wrongful termination and defemation of charater, she lied to the cops to have me arrested. I sat in an interrogation room for 3 hours under false pretenses and can never see any of my friends from work again because they all think I'm a Thief. I know Im probably not in the right thread to ask, but just curious.
  • Leave a Comment Now.

CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE Open Questions

Retail Fraud by employee

I was accussed of retail fraud. Specifically it was raincheck fraud where I issued substitutions from one video game(NOT systems only game titles) to another. The store allowes substitutions regularly on sales items, and these were. At the time of each transaction(six in all), I was not aware......

Retail Fraud at Wal-Mart, will I get a criminal record?

On March 29th, 2006, I was stopped at Wal-Mart for retail fraud. I switched the price tag of 4 DVDs. The total cost of the DVDs was just about $100 CND. I was stopped by LP and they took me to the security room in the back. I was questioned and I had to fill out forms while they called the......

Retail Fraud at Von Maur

I was caught shoplifting from Von Maur about 2 months ago, I had an arraignment sceduled about a month ago, where the judge persueded me to plead not guilty and not I have a pre-trail set for 2 weeks from now. I was told to contact the prosecutor and try to work something out, but I don't know......

Retail Fraud at Target

I am only 15 and i got caught shoplifting at target. It was stupid for me to do that because i knew i was going to get caught any ways. I stole $98 worth of cd's. It was a bad experience because i knew i shouldn't have done it but i did it. When i got caught and the person who told me to give up......

Retail Fraud At Nordstrom

I went with my friend to shoplift, this was my frist time ever and I have a clean background. Also she had put a garden tool in my purse to cut the anti theft thingy. Well I took a coach wallet to match my coach purse, and a dog sweater for my chihuahua She was afraid to shoplift since she was......

Retail fraud at Meijer

caught at meijers now what do i do next? A lawyer i called said $1500 is his charges should i just go with a public defender what are my chances of winning....

Retail Fraud at a Department Store

I stumbled across this site in my frantic search for ANY information that could give me peace of mind and some sense of what to expect. While some posts helped, there are not enough full experiences shared for those of us who come searching for some reassurance, so... here is my experience of......

Retail fraud & violating probation

I am on probation for a "speed contest" that was back in June. I was not arrested by the police. The cop just wrote me a ticket and I had to show up in court. I got pre-trial diversion for the speed contest. My terms were take a defensive driving class and probation for 1 year (no......

Retail Fraud & Theft In Michigan

I have a relative who was caught shoplifting a bottle of $7.00 bottle of body wash. He was with some friends who were shoplifting pop. The manager at the store caught his friends and when he walked out the police were there. He turned over the body wash before they searched him. This is his first......

Retail Fraud & MIP in Michigan

Well, I basically got caught shoplifting a $200 carpet cleaner plus 3 six packs of beer, and I am only 19 years old. This happened in a Meijer in Michigan and I got court at 9:00 tomorrow morning and am scared out of my mind. I'm not perticulary worried about things like fines, community service,......

Some questions maybe you're interest in...

What to do? Daughter home after 2 years, question about custody & child support

[Family Law] Massachusetts My 17 y/o daughter called last night and wants to live back home, she lives with her dad 4 miles away. My ex husband and I seperated in Nov. 2005, divorced October 2006. Joint custody with physical being given to her Dad. ( Her choice after father confided and convinced her to stay.........

changing a beneficiary

[Insurance Law] need to know legal way to sign insurance form. i am unable to write due to disability. i am able to make my mark using my mouth. please tell me how to properly use witnesses etc. i reside in Kentucky......

workers comp

[Accidents & Personal Injury Law] i am from georgia. i had a bad rotator cuff tear at work that needed open surgery. i went to one doc. who sent me back to work on modified duty. my employer said tuff and said to do my job so i tried. i rehurt my shoulder 2 days later and had to have the surgery. can i sue for my employer making.........

Supposed Contract Broken

[BUSINESS & FINANCIAL & Corporate LAW] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Connecticut Hi, I was hired to list items on Ebay for a woman in Las Vegas Nevada, where I would collect a commission on each sale. The woman claimed that she had access to a dropshipper, and instructed me to deposit the Paypal payments from the.........

Application fees

[COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION] First of all, i am in California. I have a question regarding application fees for housing. Real Estate companies make a killing around here off students just from them. Usually they are $10-25 a piece, and most of the time they dont even call you back. My gf who is a poli sci major was talking.........

Old Books & copyright

[Intellectual Property] I would like to post on a website a very short 104 page book from 1919. Free of charge to view The author had the book published in both London and NY he died in 1992. I believe he was a european (Antwerp) at the time of printing and became a US citizen later. Do you think this is public.........

state rulings

[Government & Administrative Law] If a state rules it has jurisdiction in a case and another court of the same equal rules they DO NOT have jurisdicion. Under the US Constitution can this be done by another state? I had a Texas court rule on my divorce and a year later a Utah court ruled they didn't have jurisdiction to rule.........

Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt failure

[Accidents & Personal Injury Law] What is the name of your state? Arkansas Our son was 7 weeks early and was diagnosed with hydrocephalus at 4 months. He had a Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt placed and was fine until April of this year when the catheter was obstructed. They did a revision and he was good until about 3 months later.........

Verbal Contract for tickets

[COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION] What is the name of your state? WA I received a call in regards to a craigslist post I made for 8 tickets to a soccer game. The caller was interested in buying four tickets; however I had already sold six of the eight. I offered her two tickets and she agreed to purchase the tickets and agreed.........

News: Declining Sex in Marriage - Interesting Newsweek Article......

[Family Law] "Shashay Doofray" <ShashayDoofray@yahoo.com> writes: Please also note the following paragraphs, which of course, cover what I have been saying all along. I guess it doesn't have any credibility until NEWSWEEK publishes it, even though we ALL know it's true. You mean it doesn't.........