Home » LAW »» Employment & Labor Law

X- CIA Tenet Wants to Destroy the 'Net in Order to Save It (Employment & Labor Law)

Tue, 04 Jan 2005 15:45:00 GMT
Tags: basic, bradner, cia, controlled-access, destroy, director, employment, ex-cia, george, internet, labor, law, nature, net, order, save, scott, tenet, worries

A controlled-access Internet?

By Scott Bradner

Ex-CIA Director George Tenet worries about the
Internet. He seems to think that its basic nature and
current use presents an ongoing threat that the U.S.
government may have to fix.

In his view the threat is such that the use of the
Internet, or at least the use of some networks, might
have to be restricted. To paraphrase a Vietnam-era
quote, Tenet seems to want to destroy the 'Net in order
to save it.

On Dec. 1, Tenet spoke on the topic of Democracy and
Terrorism at Federal Computer Week Events' Homeland
Security and Information Assurance Conference. Press
reports varied, maybe because most reporters were
excluded from his speech. Headlines ranged from a
positive "Tenet touts info sharing"
fcw.com/fcw/articles/2004/1129/web-tenet-12-01-04.asp
in Federal Computer Week to the threatening "Tenet
suggests
limiting the Internet to approved users"
<http://www.nwfusion.com/nlgibrad932>
in Internet pamphleteer Dave Farber's Important People list.

The main thrust seems to have been that the most
important thing that can be done in the fight against
terrorism is to properly share data between the federal
government and state and local officials and "to the
lowest levels of our society to let them take action."
But to share data this way requires a trustworthy
network, and Tenet doesn't think the Internet qualifies.

He is both right and wrong.

Part of the trustworthiness Tenet is worried about is
that of the Internet infrastructure itself. That could
be better, and it is (slowly) getting better.

Tenet wishes there were a useful public key
infrastructure but, as he points out, setting up a
national or international PKI is "a daunting task" and
one that I don't think will be done anytime soon. And
maybe that's for the best considering the
double-edged-sword nature of a PKI in that it makes
anonymity
very hard. You may not desire anonymity for a terrorist
but you might find it quite important if you needed to
contact an AIDS support center or if you were a
whistleblower or undercover police officer. I expect
that an application-specific PKI just for the
information exchange function is a lot more likely to
be deployable and would have fewer negative side effects.

Tenet would like industry to lead the way by
"establishing and enforcing" security standards and by
delivering products with a higher level of built-in
security. That would help a lot but it is nowhere near
enough. People who put data onto the Internet need to
get some clue about security. California is in the
process of notifying 1.4 million people that their
private data might have been compromised because data
that had no business being anywhere near the Internet
was on an Internet-connected machine.

Tenet said that if the Internet could not be made
secure, then maybe the government would have to build
separate networks for tasks such as information
distribution. There are many reasons why this is an
expensive and generally pointless exercise, some of
which I talked about more than three years ago
www.nwfusion.com/columnists/2001/1022bradner.html

Tenet's comment that access to the Internet might need
to be limited to people who can show they take security
seriously led to the scare headline in Farber's
posting. An attention-grabbing headline, but as likely
to happen as limiting access to the phone network to
those who promise not to talk about anti-U.S.
activities. And, sadly, about as likely to happen as
people not putting data that should not be public in a
public place such as the Internet.

Disclaimer: Harvard gets its share of
attention-grabbing headlines, mostly good. But I did
not talk to anyone at the university about this
particular one, so the above is my own ramble.
____________________________________
Bradner is a consultant with Harvard University's
University Information Systems.
<mailto:sob@lawknowledge.org.sobco.com>

--
LP

"We are fighting today for security, for progress,
and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all
men, not only for one generation but for all
generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world
of ancient evils, ancient ills."

Franklin Delano Roosevelt
State of the Union Address - 1942

Comments (0) | Promote | Bookmark |

Employment & Labor Law Open Questions

WYOMING WORKERS' COMPENSATION ACT Labor Law Poster

Your employer has qualified with the Workers' Safety and Compensation Division for the coverage of injuries arising out of and in the course of employment, while at work on or about the premises occupied, used or controlled by the employer. This coverage is for extra-hazardous industries and......

WYOMING STATE MINIMUM WAGE labor Law Poster

$5.15 per hour A training wage of $4.25 per hour is allowed for employees under age 20 during the first 90 days of employment....

Wyoming Labor Law Posters

Employment law requires that employers post mandatory Wyoming labor law posters. Each company must publish accurate and updated federal and state Wyoming labor law posters. Wyoming Labor Law Poster must Includes minimum wage, OSHA and employee right notices. Comply with Wyoming labor laws and......

Wyoming HEALTH & SAFETY PROTECTION ON THE JOB Labor law Poster

THE WYOMING OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH AND SAFETY ACT PROVIDES JOB HEALTH AND SAFETY PROTECTION FOR WORKERS EMPLOYED BY GENERAL BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY THROUGHOUT THE STATE AS WELL AS FOR ALL EMPLOYEES OF THE STATE AND ITS POLITICAL SUB-DIVISIONS. OCCUPATIONS WHICH ARE NOT AN ISSUE WITHIN THE STATE AND......

Wyoming

I am working in a supervisory position with a salary wage. I was told if icame to work as a supervisor and ifwhen I arrived I was needed to work as a regular staff member I would be paid my salary plus an hourly wage some what comprable to time and one half. almost every dayI work I am working as......

WV travel time

I drive a company issued truck with company issued tools and materials (required for work) to different jobsites each day. I am only paid to travel after I have crossed a state line. If I go anywhere regardless of time or distance in state (WV) it is not considered time worked. I have no definite......

wv- sleep time law question

I've got a question regarding sleep hours in WV. Where we work we sign a paper that shows that me acknowledge that we work a 56 hour shift and get paid for 40, this docks out 2, 8 hour sleep periods. Should employees get payed for other sleep periods after the 56 hours? What I am sayign is if I......

WV- sleep hours question

I've got a question regarding sleep hours in WV. Where we work we sign a paper that shows that me acknowledge that we work a 56 hour shift and get paid for 40, this docks out 2, 8 hour sleep periods. Should employees get payed for other sleep periods after the 56 hours? What I am sayign is if I......

WV Salary vs. Overtime West Virginia

Hello All, This is my first post, so please bear with me. I am employed as a Plant Supervisor for a Utilities Company that is currently contracted to build electric transmission lines from Pittsburgh PA to Winchester, VA, running primarily through West Virginia. My direct duties include running......

WV Salaried Employees

I work for a company which operates out of Maryland and Pennsylvania. I cannot find any specific guidelines about salaried employees pertinent to my question: I am not a contracted employee, but am considered 'salaried'. My minimum required hours are 45 per week, and of course I am not paid any......

Some questions maybe you're interest in...

Going to CS mediation

[Family Law] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? WI Hi. my wife normally posts for me here. she is Non-Mom. But she thought I would get better/more advice if I posted here myself. My ex and i went to mediation a couple of months ago to change the CO to be 50/50 custody and placement with my home.........

Breach of contract?

[Consumer Law & Fraud] Ontario, Canada. I know that this says US only, but I just need to ask. I took over the ownership of a Martial Arts club in February. At this time the club had members that had paid a 1 year membership. Currently, I have had to close this club down due to the fact that the instructor has quit.........

Liability for Medical Expenses

[Insurance Law] What is the name of your state? NY I would like some advice on the following scenario: If a relative was visiting us from a foreign country, and their Health Insurance coverage was not valid outside of the their country; what would happen if that person needed emergency medical attention and.........

Is the Patriot Act Constitutional?

[Government & Administrative Law] What is the name of your state? Ohio I've been wondering this for a while. How can the Patriot Act be Consitutional? Doesn't it go againt many right listed in the Bill of Rights? My question is why hasn't the Patriot Act been tried in the Supreme Court yet? Has it been tried in court at all.........

Social Security Disability & Alimony

[Government & Administrative Law] What is the name of your state? Mississippi I would like to know the percentage of my Disability check a judge can take for alimony in Mississippi. Yes I said alimony. My ex wife make more money than I do, but I have been court ordered to pay alimony. If I let them take it from my disability,.........

Insurance Claim Problem

[Insurance Law] My question involves insurance law for the state of: Indiana I was recently rear ended. The other driver was at fault and her insurance (State Farm) has agreed to pay for the damages. When the inspector came out, I told him that I was unsure if, but did not think that, some of the damage may have.........

Need help with estate issues

[Wills & Trusts] What is the name of your state KANSAS My grand-mother past away almost a year ago this month. She left my sister and I both $1,000 a piece in her will and everything else including her house went to our father. We were first told that we would get the money after the estate went through probate.........

application for entry of default & entry of default

[COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION] i live in arizona on 3/2/01 i was served with a civil summons. on 3/21/01 i answered the summons & sent a copy of it to the plaintiffs attorney. today i received an application for entry of default & entry of default. what does this mean? they are saying i didn't answer the.........

Taxes & divorce Illinois

[Tax Law] I got divorced in 2007. This is the first tax year that we are filing separately. As part of the agreement, I retained the family home and paid my ex $50,000 for her share of the equity. Is any portion of this amount deductible as alimony or maintenance? I was also forced to liquidate some.........

Parking in disabled spot on private property

[Traffic Law] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Arizona I live in a 44 unit, private, gated condo community in Paradise Valley. There are only 7 parking spots inside the community. 4 are handicapped. There is only 1 resident with a disabled plate. As a community we have agreed 3 of the disabled.........