Home » LAW »» Insurance Law

Help wiht ethics (Insurance Law)

Wed, 28 Jan 2009 16:24:00 GMT

What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? California,
Hello,
I have a quick question. I just filed a grievance with my health care provider and my request was refused. My wife and I just had a baby boy and we were undecided as to whether or not we wanted to have him circumcised. Upon asking our pediatrician for information about circumcision he was clearly against the procedure. He neglected to inform us that there was a 30 day time frame to that the procedure needed to be performed in order to reduce health risk and only pay our co-pay. At our next appointment when we asked for a referral to a pediatrician that performs the procedure he told us that because we were out of our 30 day window we would have to pay for the procedure out of pocket and there would be dramatic increase of health risks to our son. We filed a grievance with the hospital and requested that if we elect to have the procedure done it be at the cost of our normal co-pay. We were denied. We both feel that this the pediatrician in question intentionally withheld the information from us to put financial influence on our decision. What can we do?

Comments (4) | Promote | Bookmark |

  • Leave a Comment Now.
  • Comments
  • Thu, 29 Jan 2009 09:44:00 GMT(1)
  • I have absolutely no idea why so many people believe that their doctor/hospital/other health care provider is familar with all the specific details of the insurance policies of each and every one of their patients and can keep those details straight in their minds. Nor do I understand why so many people think it is the responsibility of the health care provider to keep them informed about what their insurance covers and the details of how to apply for benefits.
    It is not. It may, on some managed care plans, be the responsibility of the provider to submit the claim. But it is never the responsibility of the provider to know the details of your health insurance plan and explain them to you. That is your responsibility. Always.
  • Wed, 28 Jan 2009 16:59:00 GMT(2)
  • did you ever think of contacting your health insurance company and see if what they will pay for this procedure?
  • Wed, 28 Jan 2009 17:05:00 GMT(3)
  • Quote:

    Originally Posted by bwqq

    What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? California,
    Hello,
    I have a quick question. I just filed a grievance with my health care provider and my request was refused. My wife and I just had a baby boy and we were undecided as to whether or not we wanted to have him circumcised. Upon asking our pediatrician for information about circumcision he was clearly against the procedure. He neglected to inform us that there was a 3 day time frame to that the procedure needed to be performed in order to reduce health risk and only pay our co-pay. At our next appointment when we asked for a referral to a pediatrician that performs the procedure he told us that because we were out of our 3 day window we would have to pay for the procedure out of pocket and there would be dramatic increase of health risks to our son. We filed a grievance with the hospital and requested that if we elect to have the procedure done it be at the cost of our normal co-pay. We were denied. We both feel that this the pediatrician in question intentionally withheld the information from us to put financial influence on our decision. What can we do?

    I don't think it's the doctor's job to keep you informed as to your health insurance company's policies.
    While you may ~feel~ that he "intentionally withheld" info from you, you'd have to prove it. That would be quite difficult.
  • Wed, 28 Jan 2009 23:31:00 GMT(4)
  • You could have done your own research, both on your benefits and on the procedure, on your own time and within the window. You could have called and asked for the referral between appointments. I'm not violently against circumcision, but at this point since you are outside the window and the risks do go up now, why not just leave it be and let him decide if he WANTS to be circumcised when he is older? If he does develop an infection or other problem related to the foreskin, your insurance will cover the circumcision at that time because it is due to a medical diagnosis. Most insurance companies will only cover a purely elective circ within a short time after birth. Most OTHER purely elective/cosmetic procedures are not covered at all under any circumstances!
    However if you are displeased with your pediatrician, by all means find another one.
  • Leave a Comment Now.

Insurance Law Open Questions

HELP PLEASE, bad builder & same insurance as mine

I am in Pennsylvania My house has suffered damage, due to bad construction. My insurance company denied my claim. However, they said that my builders insurance should cover the cost. They even gave me a letter from their engineer, that blames the builder. I have come to find out that my builder......

Help please - Dishonest Surgery center & what can I do?

What is the name of your state? AZ Late last year I was visiting in AZ when I ruptured 3 disks in my back and had all the residual problems associated with that including surgery, medication, and finally a procedure called an injection at one of the local outpatient surgery centers. It was very......

help please

What is the name of your state? California My son is a methamphetamine addict. I contacted my HMO-Cigna and they explained the substance abuse benifits my plan includes. There are 3 levels. Intensive out patient, day treatment, and in patient. They provided me with the network facilities......

help please

What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state?new york...

Help on resolving a problem

What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state? Illinois My daughter was born with a congenital heart disease. She needed a procedure to be performed for which she was transported to another hospital using an ambulance and then back to her birth hospital after she had recovered......

Help on Auto damage issue by Condo building

What is the name of your state? Illinois I live in high-rise building and have outside parking. Few days back, building next door to mine had some stones flying in the night and broke windshields of about five cars including mine. Our building management decided to go with one particular Body......

Help Mom-Life Ins. beneficiary ?'s

What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state? NY My dad lived with another woman for 35 yrs despite still being legally married to my mom even up to the day he died. His companion is the beneficiary on his NY State pension and 2 life insurance policies totalling about $19k.......

Help me-After appendicitis operation Mediclaim is possible

What is the name of your state? TN Hi, I know something about insurance and its plans but not much.I am quite aware of health insurance.Two months ago my grandma undergone appendicitis operation.it was succeeded.Now she is in good condition.she was fifty years old.My question is, Is she......

Help Me Please

What is the name of your state? Maryland I have a Home Owners Insurance problem and need some advice as I am not sure what direction to head in at this point . back in July 19 2005 during a thunderstorm storm , as I lay on my bed I heard a loud cracking sound followed by a swooshing sound then......

Help Me

What is the name of your state? MN Last summer the city I live in upgraded the water and sewer in my neighborhood. The company that they hired to do this came in took out all the old blacktop and also dug out 3 feet below the blacktop. In the process of doing that they cut my main power cable......

Some questions maybe you're interest in...

Compensation for daughter in accident

[Accidents & Personal Injury Law] What is the name of your state? Washington State On 4/16/2005 My daughter was a passenger in my automobile. She is was 8 years old. 99.99% of the time she sits in the middle section behind the passenger side seat. On this date I allowed her to sit it the front seat of our two month old 2005.........

Collecting on judgement from Out of State employer California

[Employment & Labor Law] Hi have received a judgement that was entered in Ca Superior court. My ex employer is located in New Jersey. I was an outside employee living and working in CA so DLSE handled my case. Im trying to figure out if I have to get my judgement domesticated in NJ and if I file writ of execution do I.........

want to move husband to USA...help!

[Immigration Law] Hi all!!! Well, my husband is a UK citizen and i'm a USA citizen. We were married in the USA in June and I received my spousal visa to live in the UK...unfortunately, I WANT TO MOVE BACK HOME!!!!!!!!!!!!! My husband, being the WONDERFUL man that he is, agreed to move back to please me. We have a.........

Bankruptcy

[BANKRUPTCY & CONSUMER CREDIT] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? PA I am in the process of divorce as well as filing chapter 7. I filed chp 7 and have had the 1st meeting of creditors. One of my unsecured creditors was my father-in-law for $14000. He loaned it to my wife and I to purchase a house. There were.........

charged for the same crimes in 2 seperate counties on the same date

[CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE] What is the name of your state?TN WAS CHARGED FOR SAME OFFENSE,POSSESION OF COCAINE AND SELLING COCAINE,IN TWO SEPERATE COUNTIES ON THE SAME DATE AND TIME. SERVED 4 YEARS OF A 13 YEAR SENTENCE AND WAS PAROLED. WHAT CAN I DO TO GET THIS EXCESSIVE TIME AND THE INCORRECT CHARGES FIXED.WAS IN.........

Neighbors & dogs-What can I do?

[COURTS, LAWYERS & LITIGATION] What is the name of your state? NC The people that own the house across the street from us asked us to keep an eye on their house when they rented it. The last time they rented it, it got messed up. When the new tenants came home with a 2nd dog, we called the owners and told them. The new.........

Individual Contract

[BUSINESS & FINANCIAL & Corporate LAW] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Texas I have a contract with a hospital to perform nuclear medicine procedures. It is a very simple contract. Basically , it states that I will get paid x amount for a 40 hour work week. The term of the contract is 11/20.07 to 11/20/08. I dont get.........

Discharched & Auto in Kansas

[BANKRUPTCY & CONSUMER CREDIT] I was discharged from my bankruptsy about 2 years ago in Kansas. In the bankruptsy, we told the lawyer not to include the 2 cars as we needed them and intended to continue paying. 2 months ago I got my credit report and found that one car shows a charge off and the balance is $0. I have been.........

Does a nonprofit organization have to pay sales tax? Idaho

[Tax Law] Most religious, charitable, and nonprofit organizations are required to pay sales tax on the purchase of goods they buy for their own use and collect tax when they make taxable sales. For more information, see Sales Tax Brochure #50, Nonprofit Groups & Churches.......

non-exclusive easement

[Real Estate & Property Law] What is the name of your state?undefinedWhat is the name of your state? California What is the definition of "non-exclusive easement"?......