Home » LAW »» Real Estate & Property Law

Zoning Variance Question (Real Estate & Property Law)

Thu, 14 Jul 2005 17:19:00 GMT

What is the name of your state? Utah (City of Provo)
I purchased a property about one year ago. It is a legal duplex and my wife and I live in one half and rent out the other half to university students that attend BYU. (I guess I'm just a sucker for pain.)
The question that I have is this: Provo city has zoning ordinances that limit the number of unrelated persons who can live in a single residence. I understand this rule, as it would detract from the residential character of a neighborhood if homes were turned into boarding houses. The questionable part of the whole issue is the zoning of my property RC (residential conservation, which means that only people with deep pockets get the changes in zoning that they want). My next door neighbor is a 60 unit apartment complex, accross the street there are apartments, etc. I am one of only two houses left on the street (the other house is rented to students as well). The other half of the home that I rent out has five bedrooms and two bathrooms and I find it ridiculous that I can only rent to three people. I called the zoning office and asked them what I would have to do to get a zoning variance to rent out to more unrelated individuals. I was informed that it would require a proposal being filed and a fee being paid. I said that I would submit one but the man told me not to bother because it would be rejected. What the heck does that mean? They won't even look at it? There has to be some recourse for me, doesn't there? Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Comments (3) | Promote | Bookmark |

  • Leave a Comment Now.
  • Comments
  • Fri, 15 Jul 2005 10:42:00 GMT(1)
  • The question I have is why can I only rent to three unrelated persons when I have five bedrooms in the other half of the duplex. The condos and apartments who are my neighbors all have a minimum density of four persons per unit but the person I talked to in the zoning department said that I would never be approved for it. I would like them to increase my occupancy in the other half of the duplex from three to four or five like the neighboring properties so that I can maximize my income from rent. It seems to me, however, that they only respond to people with deep pockets in the zoning dept. I know that nobody would complain about the detrimental effects on the residential character of the neighborhood since my street is already covered by higher density housing. Anyone with experience in zoning variance law would be greatly helpful. Thanks in advance.
  • Sat, 16 Jul 2005 10:51:00 GMT(2)
  • Quote:

    Originally Posted by natetay

    The question I have is why can I only rent to three unrelated persons when I have five bedrooms in the other half of the duplex.
    **A: see below.
    *
    The condos and apartments who are my neighbors all have a minimum density of four persons per unit but the person I talked to in the zoning department said that I would never be approved for it. I would like them to increase my occupancy in the other half of the duplex from three to four or five like the neighboring properties so that I can maximize my income from rent. It seems to me, however, that they only respond to people with deep pockets in the zoning dept. I know that nobody would complain about the detrimental effects on the residential character of the neighborhood since my street is already covered by higher density housing. Anyone with experience in zoning variance law would be greatly helpful. Thanks in advance.


    **A: post the cite from the ordinance or law that you are referring to.
  • Fri, 15 Jul 2005 09:21:00 GMT(3)
  • Quote:

    Originally Posted by natetay

    What is the name of your state? Utah (City of Provo)
    I purchased a property about one year ago. It is a legal duplex and my wife and I live in one half and rent out the other half to university students that attend BYU. (I guess I'm just a sucker for pain.)
    The question that I have is this: Provo city has zoning ordinances that limit the number of unrelated persons who can live in a single residence.
    **A: a duplex is not a single residence but a 2 family dwelling property.
    **
    I understand this rule, as it would detract from the residential character of a neighborhood if homes were turned into boarding houses. The questionable part of the whole issue is the zoning of my property RC (residential conservation, which means that only people with deep pockets get the changes in zoning that they want). My next door neighbor is a 60 unit apartment complex, accross the street there are apartments, etc. I am one of only two houses left on the street (the other house is rented to students as well). The other half of the home that I rent out has five bedrooms and two bathrooms and I find it ridiculous that I can only rent to three people. I called the zoning office and asked them what I would have to do to get a zoning variance to rent out to more unrelated individuals. I was informed that it would require a proposal being filed and a fee being paid. I said that I would submit one but the man told me not to bother because it would be rejected. What the heck does that mean? They won't even look at it? There has to be some recourse for me, doesn't there? Any help would be greatly appreciated.


    **A: I don't know what your question is since you have a legal duplex, you are allowed to rent to university students.
  • Leave a Comment Now.

Real Estate & Property Law Open Questions

Zoning Variance after being issued Certificate of Occupancy

Pennsylvania We've been open for business since June of '05. We received our Certificate of Occupancy in May. The local township recently hired a new engineer who discovered our light poles are too high for local zoning. Apparently, the previous engineer didn't enforce the local zoning......

zoning use private use

fridley, minnesota-- what constitutes fair use of private property? working out of a garage becomes a business - when?...

ZONING RULE CHANGES FOR SUB-DIVISIONS

State of Ohio. Local zoning rules changed after I purchased lots in a subdivision. I want to go by the old rules. What can I do? Background: In 1940, a subdividion of 200 lots was approved. The lots had only 50 ft frontage but good depth. The lots all sold and most were built upon. In 1960, my......

Zoning Regulations & Home Owner Association

My question involves real estate located in the State of: NY Can the HOA Board of directors create new HOA rules that violate the Zoning regulations?...

zoning regulations

We live in a little township in Ohio, in a 2 bdr. 1972 trailer that is falling apart. we have 4 kids and just do not have enough room. we have found a newer trailer with 3 bdr.s and a lot more room for about $10,000. The problem is that our township has changed it's zoning regulations so that we......

Zoning R1 Used as Business

Morrow, Ohio - Salem Township -- Neighboring property zoned R1 (residential single family) was given an amendment to be a riding stable. Neighbors were not notified. No problem with riding stable; however, owner rents out for 35-50 dollars/person party areas. Drink all day, toss cans and bottles......

zoning question

looking to purchase a piece of property in Northern California (Sonoma Coast) and wish to build on it**..it is zoned as Cz - residental .Wondering what Cz means AND if I am to put a septic tank, and electricity in, is obtaining permits via the county enough ? I have asked my realtor to add a......

zoning question

What is the name of your state?Virginia I'm not exactly sure where to put this question so I guess here will work. I would like to rent a warehouse zoned as M-1 and want to know if it is able to be a private residence/work shop. Let me know if I can do this or if getting a variance or other......

Zoning Question

I live in a condo in New York City. My neighbor has knocked down one of two walls between condos probably to increase his space. Problem is, now I can hear everything they say and the barking dog. Isn't there some zoning law to prevent this invasion of privacy? What are my recourses? Thank you......

Zoning Question

What is the name of your state?New York i live next to a business in a village that we just recently found out is zoned R1, the business also has an apartment attached and they have recently expanded there parking lot to cover their entire property. we have discussed this with the code......

Some questions maybe you're interest in...

Property Lien

[BUSINESS & FINANCIAL & Corporate LAW] I am interested in knowing how to file a property lien (in the state of Georgia) in the event that a customer does not pay for services we have performed. I was told by our local county courthouse that they could not tell me how to file a property lien and that I would need to contact an attorney.........

BoxcarBill or IAAL

[Family Law] What is the name of your state? Would either of you consider helping me help the person who posted this: http://forum.freeadvice.com/showthread.php?s=&postid=392550#post392550 I would appreciate anything you can do. I've been trying but do not want to give the wrong information. Also it.........

combining/obviousness

[Intellectual Property] What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? CA I did a patent search on a simple idea that I came up with and of course the basic concept was already patented in 1996 and since abandoned. My improvement on the concept is a few minor details in design but I believe I have found a distinctive.........

health insurance & pregnency

[Insurance Law] What is the name of your state?FLORIDA My hasbend got fired from his job and we have our health insurance from the company he workd for. now I found out that I am pregnent and my question is if there is any law that protect me all the way to the end of the pregnency or they just can cancel our.........

student loan bank garnishments

[BANKRUPTCY & CONSUMER CREDIT] I am aware that the department of education can intercept tax refunds, and garnish wages, but can they put a freeze bank accounts or put liens on real estate? I am more than willing to pay this damn student loan. But the original $6000 loan is now almost $17,000. It sickens me to be manipulated.........

Colorado Workers Compensation Act Labor Law Poster

[Employment & Labor Law] NOTICE TO EMPLOYEES Your employer is insured under the above-named law by: If you are injured or sustain an occupational disease while at work, you may be entitled to compensation benefits as provided by law. WRITTEN NOTICE MUST BE GIVEN TO YOUR EMPLOYER WITHIN 4 WORKING DAYS OF THE ACCIDENT. If.........

Vacation Denied

[Employment & Labor Law] Hi I'm hoping someone out there can help me with some information for a situation my girlfriend is currently in with her present New Jersey employer regarding her vacation. Several months ago my girlfriend booked and paid for a flight to come and see me in England at the end of August this year..........

SSI/SSD Approved. Back pay questions.

[Government & Administrative Law] What is the name of your state? Texas I was approved for SSD and SSI... Here is the madness. I applied in late April, 2006. Psychiatric claim. I had no income, being recently released from prison. So I was put in for both SSI and SSDI. If I were to be approved before the 6 month wait for SSDI.........

California Workers Comp Disability Rating

[Accidents & Personal Injury Law] i was just rated 70% disabled, i read somewhere that this was a threshhold rating regarding settlement. Is it? and how so?......

switch to cobra or let them continue paying

[Insurance Law] What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state? California 4 months ago, husband was laid off. (company paid both full coverage for myself and him) (and for the record, if it has any bearing... he was a brewer for a microbrewery. the coverage was not under the brewery. it was.........